WatchmenComicMovie.com Forum

see when strongerlovingworld asked i gave him my thoughts on the concept

its just the star wars comparisons kinda drove me crazy being a huge watchmen and star wars fan - but the two don't corralate whatsoever in my opinion

_________________

Yes, it's just that me and iancontinence are starting to get off topic.

_________________
"It would be a stronger world, a stronger loving world, to die in."

-John Cale

No they don't really correlate, but what I'm trying to say is that Star Wars is to science fiction as Watchmen is to comic books, and that a lot of the broader elements are the same.

Anyway, ideas?

_________________
"It would be a stronger world, a stronger loving world, to die in."

-John Cale

Personally, I would LOVE to see a Watchmen prequel miniseries on Adult Swim/HBO.

And no, not at ALL like Happy Harry's Saturday Morning Watchmen This would be directly based on the graphic novel and movie's universe(s), and cover the activities of the heroes years before the Keene Act. Hopefully they could get all the original actors to reprise their roles.

But instead of calling it Rorschach's Journal, I think Watchmen would work just fine.

_________________

One superhero blows up New York, another one kills women and children, and the last one just flashes everybody.
SUPERHEROES ARE ASSHOLES! ~ Chester A. Bum

I think a show chronicling the Minutemen would be better, just because everyone wants something of a Rorschach spin-off.

_________________

I was considering that as well.

Maybe they could show flashback portions/episodes dedicated to the Minutemen. I always found them equally fascinating to the Crimebusters.

_________________

One superhero blows up New York, another one kills women and children, and the last one just flashes everybody.
SUPERHEROES ARE ASSHOLES! ~ Chester A. Bum

I think it would be great if "Rorschach's Journal" is a stop-motion horror/action/mystery film, like how he stalks his victims back to his lair and kills them with grotesque methods unimaginable. Reminds me of the Dexter series, by the way.

_________________
"God doesn't make the world this way. We do." - Jackie Earle Haley's Rorschach

When I saw this thread I honestly thought it was a joke, kind of like the Watchmen sequel thread. It appears not. A Watchmen film, fair enough, but I don't want anything else. We have the book, we have the book on screen, we need no more. Thats just my opinion, but seriously, a spin off/ prequel for me would definitely be a no go, even though deep down I think a prequel would be nice, if it fully charted the antics of the Minutemen, but I think we have tortured Alan Moore enough

_________________
http://www.last.fm/user/nomapple

Wait...he..does that?

Also, how do you stalk someone to your own lair? Rorschach has a lair?

_________________
"The world is a fine place and worth fighting for." I agree with the second part.

"There's a cello in your house now."

His lair is the alley, right? Actually what I meant to say is that his victims usually commits their crimes in the alley and Rorschach can stalk them there.

Or Rorschach can track his victims to their homes and kill them there, just like how he did to Grice.

_________________
"God doesn't make the world this way. We do." - Jackie Earle Haley's Rorschach

rorschach doesn't have a lair... what the hell version of watchmen did you see/read? grant morrison's? and tbone, alan moore originally planned to do a prequel for the minutemen, so it wouldn't be too bad. the only problem is that they never really started doing it, so everything would be new material.

_________________

Yeah, the lair idea has nothing to do with Watchmen. Rorschach doesn't have a lair, he lives in an apartment with a fat ugly tyrantess as a landlord.

_________________

One superhero blows up New York, another one kills women and children, and the last one just flashes everybody.
SUPERHEROES ARE ASSHOLES! ~ Chester A. Bum

That would have been really cool if they had done one

COME BACK TO THE UNIVERSE OF WATCHMEN AND WRITE A PREQUEL ALAN!

(I know he wouldn't, as that would probably get stolen by WB and made into another film, but I guess it might not because I assume Watchmen was not a box office hit, and it got mixed reviews from critics too)

URGH I just had the most revolting idea. A straight to dvd adaption of Watchmen. In other words typical shoddy quality adaption of Alan Moore's masterpiece. If WB do a straight to DVD spin off (other than ToTBF and UTH) I will scream.

_________________
http://www.last.fm/user/nomapple

Some day, in all likelihood, for whatever reason, a new Watchmen project is going to come along. Eventually, almost everything in pop culture these days gets cannibalized, bastardized, or resurrected. Ownership rights change, trademarks need to be kept viable, even the public domain ultimately asserts its rule. There's no telling what sort of project it will be or why it will be made or if it will be made out of love and affection and creative energy or purely mercenary motives. It's unlikely Moore or Gibbons will be involved (unless things change very rapidly indeed in the next twenty years) so we're going to be at the mercy of unknown forces much as Tolkien fans in, say, 1967 had no inkling of a Peter Jackson filmmaker coming along in the 21st century.

I will throw out one idea for a WATCHMEN: Next Generation: What if the ghetto kid shown on page 26, Ch. VII, tentatively raising his hand in thanks for Nite Owl's rescue (maybe it's also him on page 25, center panel; or saying "Mom? That guy in the space rocket, is that Jesus?" on page 24) is so transformed by this experience that he vows to devote his life to saving others as he was saved? Twenty years later, he befriends an aging crime fighter, his former idol, and becomes in turn Nite Owl III -- or, equally conceivably, his life in the ghetto twists him so that he becomes a new version of Rorschach....

Just one possible twist!

Personally, as I've written on another board, I wouldn't mind seeing either Minutemen adventures or "Crimebusters" stories from the 1960s, fleshed out cases alluded to in the GN or entirely new stories set in the pre-Keene era. Or post-Keeene Rorschach stories, pre-1985. If they were done with skill and care, they could be worthwhile. I would want to see a craftsman involved, not just enthusiastic fanboy types -- a REAL writer and artist who had made a mark with other work but also loved and understood the specdialness of WATCHMEN. Too many fanboys in comics and movies, IMHO, is what has made these fields increasingly derivative, imitative, and shallow. I can spot a mile away when a comic book writer only knows how to write from reading comic books or when an artist learned how to draw by copying comic book art rather than study art seriously first.

Let the brickbats be hurled!

_________________
Ego Ipse Custodes Custudio

^ I very much doubt anything will come for Watchmen in the future, except for more people liking/hating it.

_________________

Joking, of course.

...

Plus that kid was probably killed by a certain giant squid creature.

_________________
"The world is a fine place and worth fighting for." I agree with the second part.

"There's a cello in your house now."

Errrr.... My own version?

Anyway, perhaps the word 'lair' doesn't seem like a good word for Rorschach's hunting grounds, being his alley, I suppose. However, we can make an exception for his victims' homes though.

_________________
"God doesn't make the world this way. We do." - Jackie Earle Haley's Rorschach

I kind of assumed he killed criminals in the streets.

_________________
"The world is a fine place and worth fighting for." I agree with the second part.

"There's a cello in your house now."

Nahh I agree I think he takes them in to the darkest, scariest alley around, and does what rorschach does best....



As much as I love Watchmen and I love stop motion, I really don't see the 2 working together. Wrong material.

I guess what I would like best is if they fleshed out the whole book of Under the Hood in to a full series, as you often get those sorts of programmes about people's lives. I know they kind of did it on TotBF dvd, but I would prefer something more detailed. But again all this feels fundamentally wrong as I really don't think that Watchmen should be given the franchise treatment. It is like the dodgey Treasure Island sequels, or the Dracula sequel, as I regard Watchmen as a classic in it's own right, my views are LEAVE THE CLASSIC ALONE!!!

_________________
http://www.last.fm/user/nomapple

I kind of count that as the streets. He doesn't go to their homes and kill them.

I assume he doesn't.

_________________
"The world is a fine place and worth fighting for." I agree with the second part.

"There's a cello in your house now."